Showing posts with label Trading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trading. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 1, 2016

Risk management for Whales

Sunday, May 1, 2016

This week's reading

How To Think, And Act, Like A Software Executive....

With distributive technology any business can be impacted or even can be wiped out hence I agree wit what has been written by Vijay Gurbaxani in the latest issue of Harvard Business Review.

Saturday, November 22, 2014

Value at risk Shock

On october 15th, There was a turmoil in the US treasury security market. The yield on the benchmark 10 year US government bond dropped by 33 basis point to 1.86% before settling to 2.13%. This does not look much move but market participant confirmed that this was seven standard deviation move from the intraday average. Such event can occurs only once in 1.5bn years.

After this huge market volatility analyst tried to figure out the reason and even trader and regulators also wanted a understanding.
One of the explanation is provided as VaR shock. After the financial crisis, major dealer banks have curbed the capital allocation to the market making activity and VaR limits have imposed to trader or desk. If VaR limit gets breached than trader or desk has to sell off these positions. With the shockwaves of late 2008 now gradually receding, and a period of low market volatility taking its place, these VaR models have been indicating that the risk of investors sustaining large losses is very low.That means investors may be subject to a so-called “VaR shock” in the event that volatility returns to markets.
This is what happened in the market as yields dropped in the market and computer algorithms used by market making systems start buying more treasuries in order to stem their losses.
Lower risk appetite at the big dealer banks have created the effect of reducing liquidity in trading security. Market liquidity get worse in selloff periods and dealers positions, long or short, declines in the sell off periods. Dealers reduction in net positions is associated with the reduction in dealer's risk,VaR. 

“VaR-based analysis leads to self-reinforcing loops,” a group of banks warned in a presentation to the US Treasury weeks before October 15. “An unexpected increase in volatility might come from broad-based selling of assets wanting to de-risk in front of a turn of policy.”

Sunday, September 14, 2014

Flow Trading and is it different from Prop trading ?

Flow trading business is one of the main revenue source for the big investment banks. Theoretically in flow trading  trader trade financial instruments such as bonds, CDS with client's fund and he should be act in interest of client. In financial markets numerous variant of trading are happening. Basic ones are Agency Trading or Proprietary (Prop) trading and all other trading forms overlap between these.

Agency Trading: You simply execute orders for the client – you’re merely an “agent” doing what he/she wants and do not have (much) freedom.

Prop Trading: You are the principal and can make whatever trades you want, using your own money – within your trading mandate and risk limits.


Flow trading where there’s some element of agency trading but also some prop trading involved. In flow trading banks (desk) act as market maker for the clients (mostly hedge funds). Often banks uses Flow trading as  generic term for all activities done to provide and manage the desired exposure for the clients. It may involve the  market making , hedging , risk/p&l review and marking/pricing. Normally all major banks have flow trading business in Investment Grade (IG) ,High Yield (HY),Distressed Products,Loan trading  and Index segments and different trading desk has been setup for these business.

Normally Flow trader takes positions in his books based on the market sense or buying recommendation and later when client places order to buy then he decides based on resting orders and do one of the followings
  1. He off load his positions to clients obviously with making profit on that
  2. Trader buys for both for his prop books and for his client as well, obviously he continue believe in it
  3. He just act as market-maker and back-to-back it with another counterparty cheaper.
In this whole process trader tries to maximize the profit for the firm. In flow trading or market making there is lot of prop trading involved. Volcker rule has proposed to ban  prop trading so there is lot of debate whether Flow trading or market making will be permitted or not. 

Differentiating between Prop trading and Market making can be very complex. Market making is important for the clients and it is not always possible for these clients to find an market participant with opposite trade offer. As suggested by George differentiation can be done as below. 
You simply need to ask each trader how they get paid and you will know whether the firm is doing proprietary trading or market-making.This is a simple, two-step process:

  1. The sell-side will need to classify personnel as back office and front office. Then, they need to categorize all compensation paid to the front-office personnel as either commission based or P&L based.
  2. If the amount of money that is paid based on P&L is greater than the amount of money paid based on customer flow (commissions), then you are looking at a proprietary trading operation, and the firm should be held in violation of the Volcker Rule.